How to Fix an Unclear Value Proposition in Your Homepage H1
This check reads the first H1 heading on your homepage and flags it when it is missing, too short to carry meaning, or starts with "Welcome". By the end of this guide, your homepage will open with a single H1 that says what you offer and who it is for, built into the HTML your server sends.

Why it matters
The homepage H1 is one of the strongest on-page signals of what your site is about. Search engines use it to judge relevance, and AI assistants often quote it when summarizing a business. A visitor decides within seconds whether they are in the right place.
"Welcome to Example Co" or a bare logo tells none of them anything. A specific H1 such as "Bookkeeping software for independent restaurants" helps your homepage match the right queries, gives AI answers an accurate one-line description, and cuts bounces from confused visitors.
What you need
Step-by-step fix
Find every H1 currently on your homepage
Open your homepage, press F12 to open DevTools, go to the Console tab and run the snippet below. It lists every H1 in the order it appears. The first one is the one that counts. If a theme wraps the logo or site name in an H1, that logo heading is your first H1, even when your real headline appears further down the page.
[...document.querySelectorAll('h1')].forEach((h, i) => console.log(i + 1, JSON.stringify(h.textContent.trim())));Write a headline that names what you do and for whom
Use the pattern [what you offer] for [who you help], optionally followed by the outcome. Make it at least three meaningful words. Filler words such as "the", "to", "our" and "we" don't count toward that.
- Weak: "Welcome", "Home", "Example Co", "We make it simple"
- Strong: "Bookkeeping software for independent restaurants"
- Strong: "Emergency plumbing repairs across Leeds, 24/7"
Never start the H1 with "Welcome". Keep it under about 70 characters so it reads in one glance.
Make that headline the first and only H1
Put the new headline in the main hero section and mark it up as an H1. Change any other H1 elements (logo, site title, slider captions, section titles) to a lower heading level or to a non-heading element. Keep the brand name in the logo's alt text instead.
<header>
<a href="/" class="logo"><img src="/logo.svg" alt="Example Co"></a>
</header>
<main>
<section class="hero">
<h1>Bookkeeping software for independent restaurants</h1>
<p>Example Co reconciles your POS, payroll and supplier invoices automatically, so month-end takes an hour, not a week.</p>
<a href="/demo" class="button">Book a demo</a>
</section>
</main>Support the H1 with a one-line subheading
Directly under the H1, add one sentence that explains how you help, ideally with a concrete result. Together, the H1 and this line are your value proposition: who you help and how, in the first two lines of the page. Use a plain paragraph or an H2 for it, never a second H1.
Make sure the H1 is in the server-rendered HTML
If your hero text is injected by a slider, carousel or client-side script, crawlers may see an empty or different H1. Put the H1 in the page template or static content so it exists in the raw HTML response. Then confirm it from the command line.
curl -s https://example.com/ | grep -io '<h1[^>]*>.*</h1>'
Publish, clear caches and re-test
Publish the change and purge any page cache or CDN cache (plugin cache, Cloudflare, host cache). Re-run the DevTools snippet from step 1 and the curl command. Both should show your new headline as the first H1.
Then re-run the audit to confirm the check passes.
Platform-specific notes
WordPress
In the block editor, select your hero heading and set its level to H1 in the block toolbar. Many classic and block themes output the site title as an H1 on the front page. Check Appearance → Editor → Patterns → Header (block themes), select the Site Title block and change its level to Paragraph or a lower heading. In classic themes this may require editing header.php or using a child theme.
Shopify
Dawn and many Online Store 2.0 themes wrap the logo in an H1 on the homepage only, which makes your shop name the first H1. Edit it in Online Store → Themes → Edit code → sections/header.liquid. Change the H1 inside the index page-type condition to a div, then set your Image banner heading in Customize → Home page → Image banner. Check that the banner heading renders as an H1.
Wix
In the Editor, click your hero text, open Edit Text and choose Heading 1 from the theme dropdown. Change other text using Heading 1 to Heading 2–6. Under Advanced SEO, you can confirm the semantic tag is H1 independent of the visual style.
Webflow
Select the hero Heading element and set its tag to H1 in the Settings panel. Then use the Navigator to check that no other Heading element on the Home page is also H1, including headings inside symbols or components such as the navbar.
Next.js
Render the <h1> directly in app/page.tsx (App Router) or pages/index.tsx as part of the server-rendered output, not inside a component that loads with ssr: false or only after a client-side fetch. Keep layout.tsx free of H1 tags so they don't repeat on every page.
Check that it worked
✅ How to verify
- Run document.querySelectorAll('h1') in the DevTools console on the homepage. The first result should be your new headline.
- Run curl -s https://example.com/ | grep -io '<h1[^>]*>.*</h1>' and confirm the headline exists in the raw HTML.
- Use Search Console URL Inspection → View Crawled Page → HTML to see the H1 as Googlebot fetched it.
- Re-run the audit and confirm the Clear value proposition check passes with your new H1 quoted.
⚠️ Common mistakes
- Fixing the visible hero text while the theme still wraps the logo or site name in an earlier H1, so the brand name remains the first H1.
- Writing a slogan like "Built different" or "Let's grow together" that says nothing about the product or the customer.
- Starting with "Welcome to Example Co" or using only the company name as the H1.
- Putting the headline inside a banner image or a JavaScript slider, so no real H1 text exists in the HTML.
Is this still an issue on your site? Run a free audit — ZORO checks this and 294 other SEO, AI-visibility, accessibility and security signals, with fixes for your platform.
Check my site freeFAQ
Should my homepage H1 include my brand name?
Only if it also says what you do. "Example Co: bookkeeping for independent restaurants" works. "Example Co" alone does not. The brand is already in your logo alt text and title tag, so the H1 is better spent on the offer and audience.
Can a homepage have more than one H1?
HTML allows it, but it dilutes the main topic signal, and tools usually read only the first one. Use one H1 for the value proposition and H2s for the sections below it.
Should the H1 match the title tag?
They should agree but don't need to be identical. A common pattern is title "Restaurant Bookkeeping Software | Example Co" with H1 "Bookkeeping software for independent restaurants".
How long should a value proposition headline be?
Aim for roughly 4–10 words and under about 70 characters. That is long enough to name the offer and the audience, and short enough to read at a glance on mobile.
How to Fix Missing Trust Signals: Reviews, Badges & Guarantees
How to Fix Zero-Traffic Pages With No Google Impressions
How to Fix Missing About and Contact Page Links
How to Fix Decaying Traffic Pages Using Search Console Data
How to Fix Missing Privacy Policy and Terms Links
How to Fix Low-Quality AI-Generated Content on Your Site