How to Fix a Competitor Backlink Gap: Find and Win Links

A competitor backlink gap means relevant websites link to two or more of your competitors but not to you. This check needs backlink data, so it shows as not available until a backlink source is connected. By the end of this guide you will have run a link gap report, built a filtered list of realistic targets, sent tailored pitches, and set up a way to measure the gap closing.

By Updated ⏱ 3-4 hours for the first pass, then 1-2 hours per week for outreach🎯 Intermediate● High impactOff-Page
Illustration: Competitor backlink gap fix guide
OFF-PAGE · FIX GUIDE Competitor backlink gap IMPACTEFFORT TIME3-4 hours for the first pass, then 1-2 hours per week for outreach LEVELIntermediate

Why it matters

Links from sites that already cover your niche are strong relevance and authority signals for Google. They also make your brand more likely to be cited by AI answer engines, which draw on frequently referenced sources. If competitors share links from industry associations, resource pages and roundups that you lack, they can outrank you even when your content is better.

These sites have already shown they link to businesses like yours, so they are some of the most winnable link prospects you will find.

✕Beforeexample.com has 40 referring domains.85 relevant domains link to two ormore competitors, and none of them✓AfterExample Co has a tracked list of 60qualified gap domains. 12 newreferring domains have been won, and

What you need

A backlink tool with a gap or intersect report, such as Ahrefs, Semrush, Moz Pro or Majestic
Access to Google Search Console for your domain
A spreadsheet (Google Sheets or Excel) for filtering and tracking
A list of 3-5 competitors that rank for your target keywords
A business email address for outreach

Step-by-step fix

1

Choose competitors that rank, not just rivals

Pick 3-5 domains that appear in Google's top 10 for your money keywords. Your business rivals may not be the sites you compete with in search. In Google Search Console, go to Performance > Search results, sort by impressions, and search your top 10 queries in an incognito window.

Note the domains that keep showing up. Leave out giants like Wikipedia, Amazon or Reddit, because their link profiles cannot be replicated.

Pro tip: Include one competitor that is only slightly stronger than you. Their links are usually the easiest to match.
2

Run the link gap report

Enter your competitors and set your own domain as the site that does not get the link. Use the path for your tool:

  • Ahrefs: Competitive analysis > enter competitors under "Targets" and example.com under "But not this target" > choose the backlinks (Link intersect) mode
  • Semrush: Link Building > Backlink Gap > add your domain plus up to 4 competitors > select "Best" or "Weak" prospects
  • Moz Pro: Link Research > Link Intersect

Compare at the domain level, not the exact URL level, so the list stays manageable.

Pro tip: Set the filter to domains linking to at least 2 competitors. A site that links to several rivals is far more likely to link to you too.
3

Export and filter to qualified targets

Export the report to CSV and add filter columns to your spreadsheet. Then remove the following:

  • Spam, link farms and scraper sites
  • Domains with near-zero organic traffic
  • Sites outside your language or market
  • Domains where every competitor link is nofollow or sponsored, unless the site sends real referral traffic

Keep domains with real traffic that cover your topic. Sort by the number of competitors linked first, then by authority score.

text
=IF(AND(C2>=2, D2>=20, E2>=500), "Qualified", "Skip")

// C = competitors linked, D = DR/Authority Score, E = est. organic traffic
Pro tip: Open the 20 highest-priority domains in a browser before outreach. Metrics alone will not reveal expired or parked sites.
4

Classify each target by link type

Open the linking page for each qualified domain and tag the type of link it is. The type tells you what to pitch:

  • Directory or association: apply or join
  • Resource page: suggest your guide or tool
  • Roundup or listicle: ask to be included
  • Unlinked brand mention: ask them to add the link
  • Guest post or expert quote: pitch a topic or answer a request
  • Review or comparison: offer a demo or sample

Add a column for the specific page on your site that deserves the link.

text
Domain | Linking URL | Link type | Competitors linked | Our target page | Contact | Status | Date sent | Follow-up | Result
Pro tip: Directories and associations often convert at the highest rate. Handle them first, because they only need a form submission.
5

Build or improve the asset you will pitch

Look at what the competitor's linked page offers, then make sure your page is clearly better or covers something theirs does not. That could mean fresher data, an original chart, a free template, or a more complete answer. If you have nothing worth linking to for a group of targets, create one asset that serves all of them before you start outreach.

Pro tip: When a competitor's linked page now returns a 404, mention that in your pitch. You are offering a fix for a broken link.
6

Send short, specific pitches

Find the editor or page owner using the site's contact page, author bio, or a tool such as Hunter. Reference the exact page, explain why your resource fits there, and keep the email under 120 words. Send no more than one follow-up, 5-7 days later.

Do not offer payment for followed links, because that breaks Google's spam policies.

text
Subject: Addition for your "{{page title}}" list

Hi {{first name}},

I was reading your {{page title}} ({{URL}}) - the section on {{specific detail}} was useful.

I run content at Example Co. We recently published {{asset name}}: {{one-line value, e.g. a 2026 dataset of 1,200 X}}. It covers {{gap their page has}}, which could be useful for your readers.

Here it is: https://example.com/{{slug}}

Happy to send a short summary or image if that helps.

Thanks,
{{Your name}}
Example Co
Pro tip: Personalize the first line for every email. Generic templates sent in bulk get very low reply rates and can damage your domain's email reputation.
7

Re-run the gap and confirm new links

Once a month, re-run the same gap report with the same competitors and settings. Domains you have won should no longer appear in the list. Mark each win in your tracker.

Check that each new link is live, points to the correct URL, and has the expected rel attribute. Then use the updated report to choose your next batch of targets.

Pro tip: Save the report settings or project in your tool. Changing competitors between runs makes month-to-month comparisons meaningless.

Platform-specific notes

Ahrefs

The gap report sits inside Competitive analysis. You can enter up to 10 targets there. Toggle to backlinks mode and filter by "Intersect" count. The "Lost" filter in Site Explorer > Backlinks on a competitor shows links they recently lost, which make good broken-link pitches.

Semrush

Backlink Gap compares up to 5 domains in total, including yours. Click "Start outreach" to send prospects straight to the Link Building Tool, which handles contact finding and email sequences.

Moz Pro

Link Explorer > Link Intersect accepts up to 5 competitors. Sort by Domain Authority and check the Spam Score column before outreach, since anything above about 30% usually needs manual review.

Majestic

Use Clique Hunter. Enter up to 10 domains and read the matrix to find sites linking to several competitors. Trust Flow is a useful filter for topical quality.

Google Search Console

GSC only shows links to your own site, so it cannot run a gap report. Use Links > Top linking sites > Export to confirm that newly won domains are recognized by Google, which can take several weeks.

Check that it worked

✅ How to verify

  • Re-run the same gap report after 4-8 weeks and confirm that won domains no longer appear as linking to competitors but not to you.
  • In your backlink tool, open Referring domains for example.com, filter for New in the last 30 days, and match the results against your outreach tracker.
  • In Google Search Console, go to Links > Top linking sites and check that the new referring domains appear.
  • Re-run this audit with backlink data connected and confirm the check now reports results instead of showing as not available.

⚠️ Common mistakes

  • Using business rivals instead of the domains that actually rank for your keywords, which produces an irrelevant prospect list.
  • Pitching every domain in the export without removing spam, link farms and off-topic sites. This wastes time and can attract low-quality links.
  • Sending the same generic template to hundreds of contacts, which hurts reply rates and email deliverability.
  • Paying for followed links or joining link exchanges, both of which break Google's spam policies and can lead to manual actions.

Is this still an issue on your site? Run a free audit — ZORO checks this and 294 other SEO, AI-visibility, accessibility and security signals, with fixes for your platform.

Check my site free

FAQ

What is a backlink gap analysis?

It compares your backlinks with those of your competitors to find websites that link to them but not to you. Domains that link to several competitors are the most valuable prospects, because they already link to businesses in your niche.

Can I do a backlink gap analysis for free?

Only in a limited way. Free tiers such as Ahrefs Webmaster Tools and Moz's free account cap results or only show your own site. A full competitor comparison usually needs a paid plan or trial of Ahrefs, Semrush, Moz Pro or Majestic.

How many competitors should I compare?

Three to five works well. Fewer gives too small a sample. More adds noise and goes beyond what most tools allow in a single report. Choose domains that rank for your keywords and whose authority is close to yours.

How long until new backlinks affect rankings?

Google usually discovers new links within a few days to a few weeks. Ranking changes typically show up over 1-3 months, depending on the linking site's authority and relevance and on how competitive your keywords are.