How to Fix a High Spam Score of Linking Domains

This check takes the average spam score of all domains linking to your site, as reported by your backlink data provider. An average under 30 passes, 30–60 is a warning, and above 60 fails. By the end you will have audited your referring domains, removed links you control, disavowed links only if an attack is clear, and set up monitoring.

By Updated ⏱ 30–60 minutes for the audit; ongoing monthly monitoring🎯 Intermediate● Low impactOff-Page
Illustration: Spam score of linking domains fix guide
OFF-PAGE · FIX GUIDE Spam score of linking domains IMPACTEFFORT TIME30–60 minutes for the audit; ongoing monthly monitoring LEVELIntermediate

Why it matters

Google says it ignores most spammy links rather than penalising them, so a high average is usually a warning sign, not a ranking problem. It still matters in three cases. It can expose an old link scheme, such as paid links or a private blog network, that could trigger a manual action.

It can show a negative-SEO attack in progress. And it tells you your link profile has too few legitimate sites. Partners, agencies and acquirers often check this metric during due diligence.

✕BeforeAverage spam score 64 across 212referring domains, with 90 new domainsfrom .xyz/.top TLDs in three weeks.✓AfterAverage spam score 21. Self-builtdirectory links are removed, adocumented attack is disavowed, and

What you need

A backlink tool that reports spam score per referring domain (Moz Link Explorer, Semrush Backlink Audit or similar)
Owner access to Google Search Console for the site
A spreadsheet (Google Sheets or Excel)
Optional: Bing Webmaster Tools access

Step-by-step fix

1

Export referring domains with spam scores

com and open Linking Domains, then export to CSV. The export includes the Spam Score column (1–100%). In Semrush, use Backlink Audit and export the referring domains with their toxicity data.

Sort the sheet by spam score, highest first, and note the total domain count. The audit averages per domain, so 20 junk domains out of 40 hurt far more than 20 out of 2,000.

Pro tip: Add a column with the date each domain was first seen. You will need it to spot sudden spikes.
2

Cross-check against Google Search Console

Open Search Console > Links > Top linking sites > Export external links > Latest links. Match these against your high-score domains. A domain with a high third-party spam score that Google does not list is usually irrelevant.

A domain with hundreds of links in the Latest links export deserves a closer look.

Pro tip: Spam score is a third-party prediction, not a Google metric. Treat it as a triage filter, not a verdict.
3

Classify each high-score domain

Tag every domain above 60 in your sheet with one label:

  • Normal web noise: scraper sites, "website worth" or SEO-stats pages, auto-generated directories. Leave these alone.
  • Self-made: old paid links, article directories, link exchanges or private blog networks that you or a past agency built.
  • Attack signals: a burst of new domains in days or weeks, casino/adult/pharma anchor text pointing at you, thousands of sitewide links, or hacked pages linking with exact-match anchors.
Pro tip: Sort by first-seen date and chart new referring domains per week. A real attack shows up as a sharp spike, not a slow trickle.
4

Remove links you or your agency created

For self-made links, delete the profiles, directory listings or guest posts where you still have a login. For the rest, email the site owner and ask for removal or a rel="nofollow"/rel="sponsored" attribute. Log the date and response in your sheet.

This is the only step that lowers the average at its source, and it also protects you if Google ever reviews the profile manually.

text
Subject: Link removal request – example.com

Hi,

Please remove the link to https://example.com/ on this page:
https://spammy-directory.example.net/listing/123

If removal isn't possible, please add rel="nofollow" to it.

Thanks,
Example Co
5

Disavow only if an attack or manual action is evident

Skip this step if your high-score links are just normal web noise. If you found clear attack signals, or have a manual action under Search Console > Security & Manual Actions > Manual actions, create a plain-text file in UTF-8. Put one domain: entry per line and use # for comments.

com/search-console/disavow-links**, then select the property for your canonical version. Each upload replaces the previous file, so always include old entries too.

text
# Example Co disavow file – updated 2026-02-10
# Negative-SEO burst detected 2026-01-15 to 2026-02-05
domain:cheap-links.example.xyz
domain:casino-spam.example.top
domain:hacked-blog.example.net
# Single URL where the rest of the domain is fine
https://forum.example.org/thread/9981
Pro tip: Use domain: entries rather than single URLs for spam sites. They keep generating new spam pages, and URL entries won't catch those.
6

Grow legitimate referring domains

The metric is an average, so new links from clean sites pull it down. Focus on sources that reliably link:

  • Supplier and partner pages
  • Industry associations
  • Local chambers of commerce
  • Original data or tools that journalists cite
  • Unlinked brand mentions you can find by searching "Example Co" -site:example.com
Pro tip: Ten links from real businesses in your niche dilute the score more reliably than one high-authority link.
7

Re-run the audit and set up monitoring

Backlink tools recrawl on their own schedules, so wait 2–6 weeks before re-checking. Then re-export the linking domains and recalculate the average. Turn on new and lost link alerts in your backlink tool, and put a monthly reminder in your calendar to review new referring domains above 60.

Re-run this audit to confirm the average is below 30.

Pro tip: Keep your classification spreadsheet. Next month you only need to review domains first seen since your last check.

Platform-specific notes

Moz Link Explorer

Spam Score is shown per linking domain as a percentage (1–100%) in Linking Domains and can be filtered there. Moz recalculates it as it recrawls, so removed links may take weeks to disappear from the average.

Semrush

Backlink Audit uses its own toxicity scoring, not Moz's Spam Score, so the numbers won't match. You can mark domains for disavow inside the tool and export a ready-formatted .txt file. Check that file manually before uploading.

Ahrefs

Ahrefs has no spam-score metric. To spot spam, filter Referring domains by low Domain Rating, use the anchor-text report for casino/pharma terms, and sort by first seen to find spikes.

Google Search Console

The disavow tool is separate from the main Search Console interface, at search.google.com/search-console/disavow-links. If your Domain property isn't listed in the property picker, add and verify a URL-prefix property for your canonical https:// version. Limits are 2 MB and 100,000 lines per file.

Bing Webmaster Tools

Bing has its own disavow feature under Backlinks > Disavowed backlinks. It does not read Google's file, so add domains there separately if Bing traffic matters to you.

Check that it worked

✅ How to verify

  • Re-export your linking domains from the same backlink tool and confirm the average spam score is below 30, or at least trending down.
  • In Search Console, open the disavow tool and confirm your current file is listed with the correct number of domains.
  • Check Search Console > Security & Manual Actions > Manual actions shows "No issues detected".
  • Re-run this audit and confirm the check passes or moves from fail to warning.

⚠️ Common mistakes

  • Disavowing every domain above a spam-score cutoff. This can throw away links that were helping you, while Google was already ignoring the junk.
  • Uploading a new disavow file that leaves out previous entries. Each upload fully replaces the old file.
  • Expecting a disavow to lower third-party spam scores. Disavowing only tells Google to ignore links. Moz, Semrush and Ahrefs still count them, so only removal or new clean links change the average.
  • Panicking over scraper and stats sites. Every visible website attracts them, and they are not a negative-SEO attack.

Is this still an issue on your site? Run a free audit — ZORO checks this and 294 other SEO, AI-visibility, accessibility and security signals, with fixes for your platform.

Check my site free

FAQ

Does Google use Moz Spam Score or similar metrics?

No. Spam score is a third-party estimate built by backlink tools. Google uses its own systems and says it ignores most spammy links automatically.

What is a good spam score for linking domains?

This audit passes an average below 30, warns from 30 to 60, and fails above 60. Most sites have some linking domains above 60, and that is normal as long as they are a small share of the total.

Should I disavow toxic backlinks in 2026?

Usually not. Google recommends disavowing only if you have a manual action for unnatural links, or a large number of manipulative links that you or an agency built. A clear negative-SEO attack also qualifies. Otherwise, monitor and focus on earning good links.

How long does it take for a disavow to work?

Google applies the file as it recrawls the disavowed pages, which can take several weeks to months. Third-party spam scores will not change from a disavow at all.