How to Improve the Topical Relevance of Your Backlinks

Topical relevance measures how many of the sites linking to you cover the same subject area as your site. A coffee equipment shop linked mostly from coupon directories and unrelated blogs sends a weak signal, even if the link count looks healthy. By the end of this guide you will have exported your backlink profile, scored each referring domain for relevance, set a baseline, and started a prospect list of in-niche sites to earn links from.

By Updated ⏱ 3-4 hours for the audit, then ongoing outreach🎯 Intermediate● Medium impactOff-Page
Illustration: Topical relevance of links fix guide
OFF-PAGE · FIX GUIDE Topical relevance of links IMPACTEFFORT TIME3-4 hours for the audit, then ongoing outreach LEVELIntermediate

Why it matters

Search engines weight a link partly by the context it sits in: a link from a site and page about your topic passes more meaningful authority than one from an unrelated site. Relevant links also tend to send referral visitors who convert, and they shape how AI answer engines connect your brand to a subject, since those systems learn associations from the sites that mention you. A profile dominated by off-topic links can also look manipulative, which limits how much those links count.

✕BeforeExample Co (a specialty coffeeretailer) has 420 referring domains,but only 38 (9%) are about coffee,✓AfterExample Co's in-niche referringdomains have grown from 38 to 95, now21% of the profile, with new links

What you need

Verified access to Google Search Console for your domain
A backlink tool with topic or category data (Majestic, Ahrefs, Semrush or Moz)
Google Sheets or Excel
A short list of 3-5 direct competitors

Step-by-step fix

1

Export your referring domains

This check can only be scored once backlink data exists, so start by pulling a full list of sites linking to you. In Google Search Console go to Links > External links > Top linking sites > More > Export (Google Sheets or CSV). For richer data, also export from your backlink tool: Ahrefs Site Explorer > Referring domains > Export, or Semrush Backlink Analytics > Referring Domains > Export.

Merge the lists and remove duplicate domains.

Pro tip: Search Console shows a sample, not every link. Combining it with one third-party tool gives you much better coverage.
2

Tag each domain by topic

Add a column for topic. g. Recreation/Food); Semrush's Referring Domains report has a Category column.

For anything left untagged, use a keyword pattern on the domain, then manually review the remainder by opening the site. g. kitchenware for a coffee shop) and Unrelated.

text
=IF(REGEXMATCH(LOWER(A2),"coffee|espresso|barista|roast|cafe|brew"),"Relevant","Review")
Pro tip: Judge the linking page, not just the domain. A coffee guide on a general lifestyle magazine is a relevant link.
3

Calculate your relevance baseline

Work out what share of referring domains are Relevant or Adjacent. Record the number with today's date so you can track it quarterly. Then run the same tagging on 2-3 competitors that rank above you, so you know what a realistic target looks like in your niche.

text
Relevant share:   =COUNTIF(B2:B1000,"Relevant")/COUNTA(B2:B1000)
Relevant+Adjacent: =(COUNTIF(B2:B1000,"Relevant")+COUNTIF(B2:B1000,"Adjacent"))/COUNTA(B2:B1000)
Pro tip: If competitors sit at 30-40% relevant and you are under 15%, relevance is likely one of the gaps holding back your rankings.
4

Find in-niche sites linking to competitors

Use a gap report to find relevant sites that link to competitors but not to you. In Ahrefs use More > Link Intersect; in Semrush use Link Building > Backlink Gap. Enter your competitors, set your domain as the one to exclude, and filter the results to sites you tagged as Relevant.

These are your warmest prospects, because they already link to businesses like yours.

Pro tip: Domains linking to two or more competitors are the most likely to link to you as well. Sort by that count first.
5

Add niche prospects with search operators

Fill out the list with industry sources the tools miss:

  • trade associations
  • suppliers and manufacturers you stock
  • event organisers
  • niche podcasts
  • resource pages

Use the queries below, swapping in your own topic terms. Log each prospect with the page URL, the contact, and the reason a link fits.

text
intitle:"resources" "specialty coffee"
"coffee" inurl:links OR inurl:resources
"barista" "recommended suppliers"
"home espresso" "guest post" OR "contributor guidelines"
Pro tip: Ask the brands you already buy from or sell for a 'where to buy' or stockist listing. These are among the easiest relevant links to get.
6

Pitch content that fits their topic

Relevant sites link to things their readers need, so offer something specific to each one. Good options include original data (for example, a survey of 500 home brewers), an expert quote for a story they are writing, a free tool, or a detailed guide. Point the link to the matching deep page rather than your homepage, and let the anchor text describe the topic naturally.

Pro tip: Keep a 3:1 ratio of pitches to relevant sites versus everything else. Stop chasing generic directory and coupon listings entirely.
7

Disavow only manipulative links

Irrelevant links are usually harmless, and Google mostly ignores them, so do not disavow a link just because it is off-topic. Only disavow when there is a manual action in Security & Manual actions > Manual actions, or clear evidence of paid or spam links you cannot get removed. Upload the file at Google's Disavow links tool (search.google.com/search-console/disavow-links) as a UTF-8 .txt file.

text
# Example Co disavow file - updated 2026-01-15
# Paid link network, removal requests ignored
domain:cheap-links-network.example
https://spam-blog.example/best-coffee-deals.html
Pro tip: Bing has its own disavow tool under Bing Webmaster Tools > Configuration > Disavow links.
8

Re-measure every quarter

Every 90 days, re-export your referring domains, apply the same tags, and compare the relevance share against your baseline. Also check that newly earned niche links are actually indexed and live. Then re-run the site audit so this check has backlink data to score.

Pro tip: Track the count of new relevant domains per month alongside the percentage. A percentage can fall while relevant links grow, if spam links arrive at the same time.

Platform-specific notes

Google Search Console

There is no topic data. Links > External links shows linking sites and anchor text only, and the export is capped at 1,000 rows, so use it to confirm Google has seen links rather than to score relevance.

Majestic

The most direct relevance metric is Topical Trust Flow. Compare your site's top TTF categories on the Site Explorer summary with those of each referring domain.

Ahrefs

There is no built-in topic category per domain. Use Link Intersect for prospects, and filter referring domains by keywords in the domain name, or review pages manually.

Semrush

Backlink Analytics > Referring Domains includes a Category column and filter, and the Link Building Tool can send outreach emails straight from the prospect list.

Bing Webmaster Tools

Backlinks shows referring domains and lets you compare against up to 5 competitor sites. Its disavow tool is separate from Google's.

Check that it worked

✅ How to verify

  • Your relevance share (Relevant ÷ total referring domains) is higher than your recorded baseline after one or two quarters.
  • Newly earned links from niche sites appear in Search Console under Links > Top linking sites within a few weeks.
  • Majestic's Topical Trust Flow for your domain shows your core category at the top, with a rising score.
  • A re-run of the site audit now scores this check instead of marking it not applicable.

⚠️ Common mistakes

  • Disavowing harmless off-topic links. This wastes time, can remove useful links, and does not raise relevance.
  • Judging relevance only by the domain name and ignoring a relevant article on a general news or lifestyle site.
  • Buying links on 'niche-relevant' blog networks. These are often private blog networks and risk a manual action.
  • Pointing every relevant link to the homepage instead of the deep page that matches the linking content.

Is this still an issue on your site? Run a free audit — ZORO checks this and 294 other SEO, AI-visibility, accessibility and security signals, with fixes for your platform.

Check my site free

FAQ

Are backlinks from unrelated websites bad for SEO?

Usually not. Google tends to ignore low-value irrelevant links rather than penalise them. The problem is that they add little, so a profile made up mostly of them leaves you behind competitors who have relevant links.

How do I check if a backlink is relevant?

Look at the linking page's topic, the site's overall subject, and the text around the link. Tools like Majestic Topical Trust Flow or Semrush domain categories speed this up, but a quick manual look at the page is the most reliable check.

Is one relevant link worth more than many generic links?

Often, yes. A link from an authoritative site in your niche carries topical context and real referral traffic, while dozens of directory or unrelated blog links rarely move rankings.

What percentage of my backlinks should be topically relevant?

There is no fixed target. Benchmark against competitors ranking above you in the same niche and aim to match or beat their share of relevant and adjacent referring domains.