How to Fix an Unnatural Anchor Text Distribution

Anchor text distribution is the mix of visible link text other sites use when linking to you. A profile dominated by exact-match commercial keywords looks manipulated to search engines. This guide shows you how to load your backlink data, classify every anchor, find the links skewing the ratio, and rebalance the profile toward branded and natural anchors.

By Updated ⏱ 2-3 hours for the audit, then ongoing over 2-6 months🎯 Intermediate● Medium impactOff-Page
Illustration: Anchor text distribution fix guide
OFF-PAGE · FIX GUIDE Anchor text distribution IMPACTEFFORT TIME2-3 hours for the audit, then ongoing over 2-6 months LEVELIntermediate

Why it matters

Google's link spam systems and manual reviewers look for anchor patterns that natural linking rarely produces, such as dozens of domains linking with "best project management software". When that pattern is detected, Google can ignore those links, which removes the ranking value you paid or worked for. In more serious cases it issues an "Unnatural links to your site" manual action.

A branded, varied profile also helps AI answer engines associate your brand name with your topic, because they read anchors as descriptions of the target page. Note that this audit can only score the check when backlink data is available. Without a connected backlink source, it reports the check as not applicable rather than passing it.

✕Before38% of referring domains link toexample.com with the anchor "projectmanagement software", and only 12% use✓AfterMost anchors are "Example Co","example.com" or natural phrases, andexact-match anchors sit in the low

What you need

Verified Google Search Console property for your domain
A backlink tool export with anchor text (Ahrefs, Semrush, Majestic or Bing Webmaster Tools)
Google Sheets or Excel
A list of your brand name variants and target money keywords

Step-by-step fix

1

Connect or export your backlink data

The audit can only evaluate anchor distribution once backlink data is available, so start by getting a full anchor list. Use one of these sources:

  • In Google Search Console, go to Links > External links > Top linking text > More > Export.
  • In Ahrefs, go to Site Explorer > Backlink profile > Anchors and export with the Referring domains column.
  • In Semrush, go to Backlink Analytics > Anchors and export.

Where possible, count by referring domains rather than raw backlinks, because one sitewide footer link can produce thousands of backlinks.

Pro tip: Search Console caps the linking text export and shows no anchor-to-domain mapping. Use a third-party tool for the detailed work and Search Console as a cross-check.
2

Classify every anchor into categories

Paste the anchors into column A of a sheet and assign each one a category. Use these six:

  • Naked URL
  • Branded (Example Co, Example Co reviews)
  • Generic (click here, website)
  • Partial match (tools for managing projects)
  • Exact match (your exact money keyword)
  • Other

The formula below does a first pass in Google Sheets. Edit the brand and keyword patterns to match your own, then review the "Other" rows by hand.

text
=IF(REGEXMATCH(LOWER(A2),"^(https?://|www\.)|example\.com"),"Naked URL",IF(REGEXMATCH(LOWER(A2),"example ?co"),"Branded",IF(REGEXMATCH(LOWER(A2),"^(click here|here|this|website|read more|learn more|source|link)$"),"Generic",IF(REGEXMATCH(LOWER(A2),"^project management software$"),"Exact match",IF(REGEXMATCH(LOWER(A2),"project management|task software"),"Partial match","Other")))))
Pro tip: Empty anchors and image links with no alt text usually show as blank or "[no anchor]". Count them as Other, not as a problem.
3

Calculate your distribution and spot the skew

Build a pivot table with Category in rows and SUM of Referring domains in values, shown as a percentage of the total. Naturally earned profiles are usually dominated by branded and naked URL anchors. Exact-match commercial anchors typically make up a small minority.

Treat it as a red flag if:

  • exact plus partial match anchors exceed roughly a quarter of referring domains, or
  • a single money keyword appears across many unrelated domains.
Pro tip: Compare against two or three competitors ranking in the top 5 for the same keyword. That is a far better benchmark than any fixed percentage.
4

Trace the exact-match anchors to their sources

Filter the sheet to Exact match and Partial match. In your backlink tool, click each anchor to list the linking pages, then tag each source with one label:

  • Paid/guest post
  • Directory
  • Widget/footer
  • PBN/spam
  • Editorial

The usual culprits are past guest post campaigns, sponsored posts with keyword anchors, and theme, plugin or widget credit links.

Pro tip: Editorial links that happen to use your keyword are normal. Leave them alone and focus on links you or a past agency arranged.
5

Ask site owners to change or qualify anchors

For links you controlled or paid for, contact the site and ask for one of two changes:

  • swap the anchor to your brand name or URL, or
  • add rel="sponsored" or rel="nofollow" if the link was paid.

Keep the request short and include the exact page URL.

text
Subject: Small edit to your link to Example Co

Hi [Name],

Thanks for linking to us on [page URL]. Could you change the link text from "project management software" to "Example Co"? The URL can stay the same: https://www.example.com/

If the post was sponsored, please also add rel="sponsored" to the link.

Thanks,
[Your name], Example Co
Pro tip: Prioritize sitewide links and links from high-traffic pages. Fixing one sitewide footer link can move your ratio more than fifty single-page edits.
6

Disavow only manipulative links you cannot remove

If you have an "Unnatural links" manual action, or a clear paid link scheme you cannot clean up, upload a disavow file. com/search-console/disavow-links and select your property. Google already ignores most random spam, so do not disavow low-quality links just because a tool scores them as toxic.

Use domain-level entries for networks.

text
# Example Co disavow file - updated 2026-01-15
# Paid guest post network, removal requests ignored
domain:spammy-blog-network.example
domain:cheap-links.example
https://random-directory.example/listing/example-co
Pro tip: Uploading a new file replaces the old one. Always edit and re-upload the complete list.
7

Change how you earn new links going forward

Rebalancing mostly happens by adding natural links, not by removing old ones. Take these steps:

  • Stop specifying keyword anchors in guest post, PR and partnership briefs.
  • Give partners a link snippet that uses your brand name.
  • Pitch data, tools and quotes that journalists naturally cite as "according to Example Co".
  • In widgets or embeds you distribute, use a branded, nofollow credit link.
html
<a href="https://www.example.com/" rel="nofollow">Example Co</a>
Pro tip: Unlinked brand mentions are easy wins. Search for your brand name without a link and ask those sites to link it.
8

Re-run the audit and track the ratio monthly

Make sure your backlink source is connected so the audit can score this check instead of reporting it as not applicable. Then re-run the audit. Re-export anchors each month and update your pivot table to track the trend.

Expect gradual change, because crawlers take weeks to pick up edited anchors and new links.

Pro tip: Add a date column to each export and chart the Exact match percentage over time. A steady downward line is the goal.

Platform-specific notes

Google Search Console

Links > External links > Top linking text shows anchors but not which domain uses each one. It is free and reflects Google's own data, but it is sampled and capped, so pair it with a third-party tool for source-level work.

Bing Webmaster Tools

Go to Backlinks and export the list for your site, which includes anchor text per linking URL. It is a free alternative if you have no paid backlink tool. Bing also has its own Disavow Links tool under the same section.

Ahrefs

Site Explorer > Backlink profile > Anchors groups anchors by referring domains and shows first-seen dates. Use the dates to see which anchors came from a past link campaign. You can filter Backlinks by anchor text to find each source page.

Semrush

Backlink Analytics > Anchors lists anchors with domain and backlink counts. Backlink Audit lets you mark links for removal outreach and generates a disavow file. Review that file manually before uploading it.

WordPress themes and plugins

If you distribute a theme, plugin or widget with a footer credit like "Best project management software by Example Co", change it to a branded anchor with rel="nofollow" in the next release. Thousands of sites updating the template will shift your profile quickly.

Check that it worked

✅ How to verify

  • Re-run the audit with backlink data connected and confirm the Anchor text distribution check returns a score instead of not applicable.
  • Re-export anchors from Ahrefs or Semrush and confirm the Exact match share by referring domains has dropped since your baseline.
  • Spot-check five pages where you requested edits and confirm the anchor now reads "Example Co" or the URL, or that it carries rel="sponsored".
  • In Search Console, open Security & Manual Actions > Manual actions and confirm it shows "No issues detected".

⚠️ Common mistakes

  • Counting raw backlinks instead of referring domains, so one sitewide footer link makes the profile look far worse or better than it is.
  • Mass-disavowing every exact-match or "toxic" link, which can remove genuine editorial links that were helping rankings.
  • Overcorrecting by buying new links with branded anchors. Paid links are still a link scheme regardless of anchor text.
  • Swapping all keyword anchors to the identical brand phrase on the same pages at once, which creates a new unnatural pattern.

Is this still an issue on your site? Run a free audit — ZORO checks this and 294 other SEO, AI-visibility, accessibility and security signals, with fixes for your platform.

Check my site free

FAQ

What is a good anchor text ratio for SEO?

Google publishes no target ratio. Natural profiles are usually dominated by branded and naked URL anchors, with exact-match keyword anchors in a small minority. The most reliable benchmark is the distribution of competitors ranking well for the same keywords.

Can too many exact-match anchors cause a Google penalty?

Yes, if they come from manipulative links. Google's spam systems usually just ignore those links, which cancels their value. Clear link schemes can also trigger a manual action, shown in Search Console under Manual actions.

Should I disavow links with exact-match anchor text?

Only if they come from links you paid for or arranged and cannot get removed, or if you have a manual action. Editorial links that happen to use your keyword should be kept.

How long does it take to fix anchor text distribution?

Edited anchors are picked up as pages are recrawled, typically within weeks. A meaningful shift in the overall ratio usually takes two to six months of earning new, naturally anchored links.