How to Fix an Authority Gap vs. Competitors (Backlinks)

This check compares how many unique websites (referring domains) link to you with the median of your top search competitors. If you have under 60% of that median, you get a warning; under 25%, it fails. By the end of this guide you will have a target number, a qualified list of link-gap domains, and an outreach plan to close the gap.

By Updated ⏱ 4-6 hours to build the list, then 2-4 hours per week for 2-3 months🎯 Advanced● High impactOff-Page
Illustration: Authority gap vs. competitors fix guide
OFF-PAGE · FIX GUIDE Authority gap vs. competitors IMPACTEFFORT TIME4-6 hours to build the list, then 2-4 hours per week for 2-3 months LEVELAdvanced

Why it matters

Referring domains are still one of the strongest signals separating pages that rank in the top three from pages stuck on page two. When competitors have several times more independent sites vouching for them, Google and AI answer engines that rely on search results will cite them first, even if your content is as good. Sites that already link to two or more competitors have shown they link out in your topic, so they convert far better than cold outreach.

✕BeforeYou have 48 referring domains; topcompetitors have rival-a.com 310,rival-b.com 420, rival-c.com 960✓AfterYou have 260 referring domains againsta competitor median of 420 (ratio 0.62= pass).

What you need

Your audit result showing your referring domains and each competitor's count
A backlink tool with a link-intersect feature (Ahrefs, Semrush or Moz Pro)
Google Search Console access for your domain
A spreadsheet (Google Sheets or Excel) to track prospects and outreach
A business email address on your own domain for outreach

Step-by-step fix

1

Calculate your referring-domain target

Take the competitor referring-domain counts from the audit detail, sort them from lowest to highest and pick the middle value; with an even number of competitors, use the higher of the two middle values. Multiply that median by 0.6 to get the pass threshold and by 0.25 to get the minimum to leave the fail zone. The check counts unique linking domains, not total backlinks, so 50 links from one site count as one.

text
Competitors: 310, 420, 960
Median = 420
Pass target  = 420 x 0.6  = 252 referring domains
Warn floor   = 420 x 0.25 = 105 referring domains
You today    = 48  -> need +57 to reach warn, +204 to pass
Pro tip: If one competitor is a huge marketplace or publisher you do not really compete with, update the "What you offer" setting so the competitor set reflects real rivals; the median will be more realistic.
2

Run a link intersect against your competitors

Enter your domain plus the competitor domains from the audit in a link-gap tool and set it to show domains linking to at least 2 competitors but not to you.

  • Semrush: SEO > Link Building > Backlink Gap, select "Best" or "Weak" prospects.
  • Ahrefs: Competitive Analysis, choose the Backlinks view, set "Show domains that link to" at least 2 of the targets but not your site.
  • Moz Pro: Link Research > Link Intersect.

Export the full list to your spreadsheet.

Pro tip: Use root-domain mode (*.example.com) for both you and competitors, otherwise you miss links pointing to subdomains or deep pages.
3

Qualify and categorise the prospects

Remove spam, scraper sites, foreign-language link farms and domains with no organic traffic. Then open each remaining linking page and tag it by link type, because each type needs a different action:

  • Directory / association / chamber listing
  • Supplier, partner or customer page
  • Best-of list or comparison article
  • Resource or tools page
  • News or guest article

Sort by how many competitors each domain links to; domains linking to 3+ rivals go to the top.

text
Columns: Domain | Linking URL | Competitors linked | Link type | Contact | Status | Date contacted | Live link URL
Priority formula (Google Sheets): =IF(C2>=3,"P1",IF(C2=2,"P2","P3"))
Pro tip: Nofollow links still add a referring domain in most backlink tools, so do not discard a relevant prospect just because competitor links are nofollow.
4

Take the quick wins first

Directory, association and partner links need a form or one email, not a pitch. Claim every listing your competitors have that you are eligible for, ask suppliers and partners to add you to their "Where to buy" or "Partners" pages, and convert unlinked brand mentions into links. Find mentions with search operators and ask the author to link the existing mention.

text
"Example Co" -site:example.com
"Example Co" -site:example.com -site:linkedin.com -site:facebook.com -site:x.com
intitle:"partners" "rival-a.com" OR "Rival A"
Pro tip: Set up a free mention alert (Google Alerts or your backlink tool's mention tracker) for your brand name so new unlinked mentions reach you within days.
5

Pitch list articles and resource pages

For best-of lists, comparisons and resource pages, send a short personal email to the author or editor. Reference the exact article, state why your product or page fits its criteria, and give them something concrete: a spec, pricing, a free account for testing, or a quote. Follow up once after 5-7 days, then stop.

text
Subject: Addition for "Best project tools for small agencies"

Hi Sam,

Your list on site.example.org compares Rival A and Rival B on pricing and client portals. Example Co covers both and adds unlimited guests on the free plan, which none of the listed tools offer.

Happy to set up a full account for you to test, and here is a one-line summary you can use:
"Example Co: client portals with unlimited guests, free up to 5 projects." https://example.com/

Thanks,
Alex, Example Co
Pro tip: Update lists first: articles updated in the last 12 months are far more likely to be edited again than ones untouched for years.
6

Build one asset that earns links at scale

Outreach alone rarely closes a gap of hundreds of domains. Publish one piece that journalists and bloggers cite: original survey data, an industry benchmark, a free calculator or a regularly updated statistics page on example.com. Promote it to the news and resource-page prospects from your list and answer relevant journalist requests on platforms such as Qwoted, Featured or Source of Sources.

Pro tip: Give the asset a stable URL (e.g. example.com/research/2026-benchmark) and update it annually instead of publishing a new URL each year, so links keep accumulating on one page.
7

Track progress and re-run the audit

Log every won link in your spreadsheet and check your referring-domain count monthly in the same backlink tool. Backlink indexes typically take 2-8 weeks to discover new links, so re-run the audit about a month after a batch of wins. Compare your new count to the pass target from step 1, and note that competitors also gain links, so the median may rise.

Pro tip: Also check for lost links each month; recovering a lost referring domain is usually easier than earning a new one.

Platform-specific notes

Semrush

Backlink Gap is under SEO > Link Building > Backlink Gap and compares up to 5 domains. Use the "Best" tab for domains linking to all competitors but not you, and "Send to Link Building Tool" to manage outreach inside Semrush.

Ahrefs

Link Intersect now lives in Competitive Analysis. Enter competitors as targets and your domain in the "but doesn't link to" field; switch the mode to the full domain to avoid missing subdomain links.

Moz Pro

Use Link Research > Link Intersect with "root domain" selected. Moz's index is smaller, so counts will be lower than in other tools; compare yourself to competitors within the same tool rather than mixing sources.

Google Search Console

Links > Top linking sites > Export shows domains Google already knows link to you. Cross-check it against your prospect list so you do not pitch sites that already link to you, since third-party tools may not have found them yet.

Check that it worked

✅ How to verify

  • Re-run the audit and confirm your referring-domain count divided by the competitor median is at least 0.6 (status: pass).
  • In your backlink tool, filter referring domains by "First seen" for the last 30-90 days and match them to the wins in your tracking sheet.
  • Run the link intersect again; domains you secured should no longer appear as linking to competitors but not to you.
  • Check Google Search Console > Links > Top linking sites for the new domains after Google recrawls them.

⚠️ Common mistakes

  • Counting backlinks instead of referring domains: 200 links from one partner site still add only one referring domain to this check.
  • Buying bulk links from PBNs or link farms to hit the number quickly; they inflate counts briefly and risk a manual action or being ignored by Google.
  • Comparing yourself to the wrong competitors, such as large marketplaces or media sites, because "What you offer" is vague, which makes the median unreachable.
  • Stopping after the first wave of outreach; competitors keep earning links, so the gap reopens without a steady monthly process.

Is this still an issue on your site? Run a free audit — ZORO checks this and 294 other SEO, AI-visibility, accessibility and security signals, with fixes for your platform.

Check my site free

FAQ

How many referring domains do I need to compete?

For this check, at least 60% of the median referring-domain count of your top search competitors. If the middle competitor has 400, aim for 240 or more. The right number differs by niche, which is why it is measured against your actual rivals rather than a fixed figure.

What is a link intersect or backlink gap analysis?

It is a report that lists websites linking to one or more of your competitors but not to you. Sites linking to two or more competitors are the best prospects because they already link to businesses like yours.

Do nofollow links count toward referring domains?

Most backlink tools count a domain as referring whether its links are followed or nofollow, so they raise your count for this check. Google treats nofollow as a hint, so followed editorial links from relevant sites remain more valuable for rankings.

How long does it take to close a backlink gap?

Quick wins such as directories, partner pages and unlinked mentions can add domains within weeks. Closing a large gap usually takes 3-6 months of consistent outreach plus at least one linkable asset, and tools may need 2-8 weeks to index each new link.