How to Fix Toxic and Spammy Backlinks Without Over-Disavowing
Your audit flagged a high backlink spam score. It warns from 30/100 and fails from 60/100, based on how many of your referring domains look like link farms, PBNs, hacked pages or auto-generated spam. By the end of this guide you will have triaged your referring domains, removed or disavowed the links that are clearly manipulative, and set up monitoring so the score trends down.

Why it matters
Google's spam systems ignore most junk links, so random spam rarely hurts rankings. The risk comes from link schemes tied to you, such as paid links, PBNs or private blog networks a previous agency built. These can trigger a manual action (an "Unnatural links" penalty) that removes pages from results.
A spam-heavy profile also tells partners, buyers and AI-driven research tools that your authority is inflated, and a high score can hide a real negative-SEO or hacked-site pattern you should know about.
What you need
Step-by-step fix
Check Search Console for a manual action first
In Google Search Console open Security & Manual Actions > Manual actions. If you see "Unnatural links to your site", disavowing and cleaning up is mandatory, and you will finish with a reconsideration request. If it says "No issues detected", you are doing preventive cleanup, so be conservative.
Also open Links > Top linking sites > More > Export to get Google's own view of who links to you.
Export referring domains with spam metrics
Work at the domain level, not individual links. Pull a full referring-domains list that includes the spam metric, anchor text, first-seen date and dofollow/nofollow status:
- Ahrefs: Site Explorer > Referring domains > Export
- Semrush: Link Building > Backlink Audit > Audit tab, sorted by toxicity
- Moz: Link Explorer > Spam Score tab
Merge the export with the Search Console list in one sheet.
Triage domains into ignore, remove and disavow
Sort by spam metric descending and label each domain. A high score alone is not proof that a link is manipulative. Ignore scrapers, stats/whois sites, foreign-language directories and nofollow spam, because Google already discounts them.
Mark remove/disavow only for clear patterns:
- PBNs with thin posts and exact-match money anchors
- Paid or sponsored links without rel="sponsored" that you or an agency bought
- Link networks: dozens of domains on the same IP or template, linking sitewide
- Hacked pages injecting your URL next to casino or pharma links
Domain,SpamScore,Anchor,Follow,Pattern,Action seo-links-hub.example,88,best crm software,dofollow,PBN,disavow whois-stats.example,71,example.com,nofollow,scraper,ignore partner-blog.example,12,Example Co,dofollow,editorial,keep
Request removal of links you or an agency created
For paid placements, guest posts with money anchors, or network links you can trace to a past vendor, email the site owner or vendor. Ask them to remove the link or add rel="sponsored" or rel="nofollow". Record the date, contact and response in your sheet.
Removal is the only action that lowers third-party spam scores directly, because the link disappears from every crawler's index.
Subject: Link removal request – example.com Hi, Please remove the link to https://example.com/pricing on https://seo-links-hub.example/top-crm-tools, or add rel="sponsored". Thanks, Example Co
Build a domain-level disavow file
Create a UTF-8 plain-text file listing only the domains you labelled disavow. Use domain: lines so every URL on that host is covered, and add # comments for your own records. The file limits are 2 MB and 100,000 lines.
Uploading a new file replaces the previous one, so always merge with any existing file before you upload.
# Example Co disavow file – updated 2026-03-10 # PBN network identified via shared template/IP domain:seo-links-hub.example domain:best-crm-reviews.example # Paid links from former agency, removal refused domain:guestpost-network.example # Single hacked page (domain itself is legitimate) https://smallbiz-blog.example/wp-content/uploads/cache/page.html
Upload the file to Google and Bing
com/search-console/disavow-links, choose the property and click Upload disavow list. If the site uses both a domain property and URL-prefix properties, upload to the property that covers the linked URLs. In Bing Webmaster Tools use Configuration > Disavow links and add the same domains.
If you had a manual action, submit a reconsideration request afterwards that explains the removals and the disavow.
Mark disavowed domains in your backlink tool
Third-party spam scores do not read Google's disavow file. Mark the same domains as disavowed or hidden in your tool so its view matches yours:
- Semrush: select the domains in Backlink Audit > Disavow
- Ahrefs: add them to the site's disavow list in Site Explorer
Alongside this, keep earning relevant editorial links through digital PR, partner pages, supplier and customer listings, and original data. A larger base of clean domains lowers the spam share over time.
Re-run the audit and monitor monthly
After your backlink provider recrawls, usually 2-6 weeks later, re-run the audit and confirm the spam score is below 30. Set up a new referring domains alert in your tool so you can review new spam monthly, and recheck Manual actions in Search Console each quarter.
Platform-specific notes
Google Search Console
The disavow tool is not linked from the main menu. Open it directly at search.google.com/search-console/disavow-links. One file per property, and each upload replaces the previous file. Restricted users cannot upload.
Bing Webmaster Tools
Bing handles disavows per URL, directory or domain in its own interface, not by file upload. It does not read Google's file, so you have to add the same domains separately.
Semrush
Backlink Audit lets you move domains to a Disavow list and export a Google-formatted .txt. You can also import your existing Google file so the tool stops counting those domains in its scores.
Ahrefs / Moz
Moz Spam Score is a per-domain percentage based on shared features of penalized sites. It describes risk, not a penalty. Ahrefs has no spam score, so judge PBN patterns using its Domain Rating, traffic and outgoing-link columns.
WordPress / Cloudflare
Plugins and firewall rules cannot remove inbound links. Blocking referrers in Cloudflare does nothing for SEO. If spam links point to URLs on your site that don't exist (hacked-site leftovers), return 410 for those paths so the links lose their target.
Check that it worked
✅ How to verify
- Re-run the audit after your backlink provider recrawls and confirm the spam score is under 30/100 (under 60 at minimum to clear the fail).
- In Google's disavow tool, open the property and confirm it shows the current file with the expected line count and upload date.
- In Search Console > Security & Manual Actions > Manual actions, confirm the status is "No issues detected".
- Spot-check five removed links by loading the source pages and confirming the link is gone or now carries rel="sponsored"/"nofollow".
⚠️ Common mistakes
- Disavowing everything your tool flags as toxic, including legitimate small sites. This can throw away links that were actually helping you rank.
- Uploading a new disavow file that overwrites the old one instead of merging the two lists.
- Expecting the Google disavow file to lower third-party spam scores. It doesn't, so mark the domains in your backlink tool as well.
- Disavowing individual URLs from a network that spans whole domains, which leaves the other pages on those domains still counting against you.
Is this still an issue on your site? Run a free audit — ZORO checks this and 294 other SEO, AI-visibility, accessibility and security signals, with fixes for your platform.
Check my site freeFAQ
Do toxic backlinks actually hurt my Google rankings?
Usually not. Google says its systems ignore most spammy links automatically. They hurt when they form a link scheme associated with you, such as paid or PBN links, especially if that leads to a manual action.
Should I disavow links if I have no manual action?
Only if you know or strongly suspect that you, or someone working for you, built manipulative links. Random spam you didn't create can be ignored.
How long does it take for a disavow to work?
Google applies it as it recrawls each linking page, which typically takes several weeks to a few months. Third-party spam scores update on their own recrawl schedule.
What spam score is considered bad?
This audit warns at 30/100 and fails at 60/100. Below 30 is normal for most sites, since every site attracts some scraper and directory links.
How to Fix an Unnatural Anchor Text Distribution
How to Fix an Authority Gap vs. Competitors (Backlinks)
How to Fix a Skewed Follow / Nofollow Backlink Ratio
How to Increase Referring Domains to Your Website
How to Fix Lost Backlinks and Reclaim Link Equity
How to Build Brand Visibility With Q&A Platform Answers